Newsletter · The Recognition Economy · Season 3

The Decision

· 2 min read

Originally published on LinkedIn →

S3: E13

Twelve weeks. Forty-eight posts. One idea explored from every angle.

The Recognition Economy.

We started with convergence, the blurring lines between promotional products and incentive marketing. We explored the buyers, the products, the stakes, the infrastructure, the integration, the participants, the measurement, and the supplier strategies that separate winners from the rest.

This final week, I want to give you something practical. A framework for the decision that sits at the center of everything we've discussed: how to choose a supplier in the Recognition Economy.

Because if you're a buyer reading this, a program manager, an HR leader, a procurement professional, you've probably realized that the old selection criteria don't work anymore. Price, catalog breadth, and delivery speed used to be enough. They're not.

Here's the framework I'd use if I were choosing a supplier today:

First: Do they specialize?

The generalist era is ending. You want a supplier who goes deep in their category--who lives and breathes it, who curates rather than aggregates, who can tell you why this product over that one based on participant data and experience.

A specialist brings expertise a generalist can't match. They know what works because they've seen it work hundreds of times in their specific domain.

Second: Can they integrate?

Ask them to describe their integration capabilities with your HRIS. If the answer is vague, "we can work with your team", that's a red flag. The winners have pre-built integrations, documented APIs, and implementation timelines measured in weeks, not months.

Integration isn't optional anymore. It's the infrastructure that makes everything else possible.

Third: Do they measure what matters?

Ask them how they'll help you prove ROI. Not redemption rates, those are table stakes. Real outcomes: retention correlation, engagement impact, participant satisfaction beyond a simple survey.

The suppliers who can help you build a measurement framework that connects program activity to business outcomes are the ones worth partnering with long-term.

Fourth: Do they think like a partner?

This is the hardest one to evaluate, but the most important. A vendor answers your questions. A partner asks better ones. A vendor delivers what you ordered. A partner challenges whether what you ordered is what you actually need.

Listen to how they talk in the sales process. Are they pitching products or asking about your goals? Are they quoting prices or discussing outcomes? Are they selling a transaction or proposing a relationship?

Fifth: Do they understand the participant?

Ask them to describe the ideal participant experience from trigger to delivery. If they can't articulate it in detail, if they jump straight to catalog and logistics, they haven't done the work.

The best suppliers design backward from the participant moment. Everything else is infrastructure in service of that experience.

That's the framework. Five questions. Five filters. And if a supplier passes all five, you've probably found a partner worth investing in.

This has been Season 3. The Recognition Economy. Thank you for reading, for engaging, for pushing back, and for building alongside me.

The economy is real. The opportunity is enormous. And the suppliers and buyers who see it clearly will shape what comes next.

Working for You,

Jon Alexander, MAS

Originally published on LinkedIn →