Newsletter · The Recognition Economy · Season 3
The Measurement
Originally published on LinkedIn →
S3: E10
We've talked about products. We've talked about infrastructure. We've talked about integration and participant experience.
But there's a question that sits underneath all of it, one that most program managers can't answer with confidence:
How do you know if it's working?
Not "are people redeeming?" That's activity, not impact. Not "is the budget being spent?" That's administration, not measurement. The real question is: Is this recognition program actually changing behavior, improving retention, and strengthening the relationship between the company and its people?
And the honest answer, for most programs, is: we don't know.
Here's why that's a problem.
Recognition programs compete for budget with every other HR initiative. Learning and development. Wellness programs. Compensation adjustments. Benefits enhancements. Every one of those has advocates making the case for more funding.
If you can't prove your recognition program is delivering measurable outcomes, you lose that budget fight. Maybe not this year. But eventually.
I've watched it happen. A company invests $500K in a recognition program. Three years in, a new CHRO arrives and asks: "What's the ROI on this?" The program manager pulls up redemption rates and participation numbers. The CHRO says: "That tells me people are using it. It doesn't tell me it's working."
Six months later, the budget is cut by 40%.
That's not a measurement failure. That's a storytelling failure. The program was probably working, retention in recognized cohorts was likely higher, engagement scores were likely better, time-to-productivity for new hires was likely shorter. But nobody was tracking those metrics against program participation.
The measurement framework I've started using with my clients has three layers:
Activity metrics: Redemption rates, time-to-redemption, catalog engagement. These tell you the program is functioning.
Experience metrics: Participant satisfaction surveys, NPS on the recognition experience, qualitative feedback. These tell you the program feels right.
Outcome metrics: Retention rates for recognized vs. non-recognized employees, engagement score correlation, manager satisfaction with program tools. These tell you the program is working.
Most programs only measure layer one. The good ones measure layers one and two. The great ones measure all three, and they're the ones that never lose budget fights.
Because when you can say "recognized employees are 23% more likely to stay past their two-year mark," that's not a recognition program. That's a retention strategy with a measurable ROI.
Measurement isn't about proving the program works. It's about proving it matters. And in the Recognition Economy, the programs that can prove they matter are the ones that grow.
Working for You,
Jon Alexander, MAS