Newsletter · The Recognition Economy · Season 3

The Stakes

· 2 min read

Originally published on LinkedIn →

Season 3: Episode 4

There's a moment in every recognition program where it stops feeling like recognition and starts feeling like a transaction.

You've seen it. The employee hits their five-year anniversary. An email arrives.

"Congratulations! Click here to select your gift from our catalog." They scroll through a page of generic options, a watch they'd never wear, a blanket they don't need, a Bluetooth speaker from a brand they've never heard of.

They pick something. It arrives in a brown box two weeks later. They open it, shrug, and put it in a drawer.

That's not recognition. That's procurement with extra steps.

And here's the thing: the company spent real money on that moment. Maybe $150, maybe $300. But because the experience felt transactional--because it lacked intention, curation, and care, the investment was wasted.

The participant didn't feel valued. They felt processed.

This is the stakes of the Recognition Economy. It's not about whether companies spend money on recognition. They already do. It's about whether that spending creates the feeling it's supposed to create.

And right now, most of it doesn't.

I talk to program managers who tell me their redemption rates are great. "85% of participants redeem within 30 days!" But when I ask them how those participants felt about what they received, whether it changed their perception of the company, whether it made them more likely to stay, they don't know. They've never measured it.

Because we've been measuring the wrong things. Redemption rate tells you people clicked a button. It doesn't tell you the recognition landed.

The stakes are higher than most people realize. A bad recognition experience isn't neutral--it's negative. It tells the employee: "We checked a box. You're a line item." And in a labor market where people have options, that message has consequences.

The companies getting this right are the ones who treat recognition like a brand experience. They curate. They personalize. They invest in products that have staying power. They design moments that feel intentional.

And they're seeing the results in retention, engagement, and employer brand perception.

The stakes are real. The question is whether your program is meeting them.

Working for You,

Jon Alexander, MAS

Originally published on LinkedIn →